COVID-19 UPDATE: Our warehouse is OPEN and we are shipping orders daily | FREE Lavari Jewelers hand sanitizer with purchase over $50

No products in the cart.

Top 10 Sweetest Day Gifts for Your Girlfriend

National Sweetest Day is one of the most low-key romantic holidays of the year. It’s observed on the third Saturday of October, meaning October 19 is the date to mark on your 2019 calendar.

Quick History of Sweetest Day

The holiday takes its name from something literally sweet ⁠— candy! Legend said an Ohio candy company started the holiday to bring joy to people. Employees would bring candy and small gifts to kids and the elderly to show them they were loved. The holiday quickly spread through the Midwest to the coasts, and Sweetest Day in the United States broadened to include family and friends.


Most people celebrate Sweetest Day just like Valentine’s Day. Candy is still a common gift, along with flowers, cards, and beautiful jewelry. Check out our top 10 Sweetest Day gift ideas for your girlfriend to find the perfect way to remind her how much she means to you!

Our Top 10 Sweetest Day Gift Ideas for Your Girlfriend


1. Beautiful Birthstone Ring

A birthstone ring is one of the most meaningful Sweetest Day gifts you can buy. Select her birthstone and watch it sparkle in this cushion-cut ring with a white sterling silver band. The timeless, simple design makes it ideal for everyday wear. She’ll think of you whenever she sees it throughout the day!

Not sure what her birthstone is or want to know more about the precious gemstone you’re about to choose for your special Sweetest Day gift for her? Read our complete guide to birthstones before making your selection.

A meaningful Sweetest Day gift for your girlfriend who loves:

  • Jewelry with meaning and importance
  • Wearing dazzling jewelry to accent her personal style
  • Daily reminders of your love

2. Radiant Flora Necklace in Mother of Pearl or Classic Black Onyx

A whimsical, contemporary, and beautiful Flora necklace will bring her luck, versatility, positivity, and awesomeness! Our lovely flora pendant comes in radiant mother of pearl and pink silver or classic black onyx and silver. Both dangle on an adjustable 16-18” matching silver chain. The secure lobster lock will keep it safe around her neck forever. 

An excellent Sweetest Day gift for your girlfriend who loves:

  • Jewelry she can wear with everything
  • Classic, delicate styles
  • You and the laid-back relationship you share!

3.  Dazzling Sterling Silver & Cubic Zirconia Tennis Bracelet

This black and thin blue line bracelet incorporates rugged military style with cubic zirconia diamonds for a stunning adornment for his wrist. The thin blue lines show support for law enforcement, and written inside is “Blue Lives Matter,” adding deeper meaning to this handsome bracelet. The fold-over closure and bracelet length are designed for an active man and make a great gift for police officers!

Looks great worn with:

  • A long sleeve shirt, structured pants, and brogues
  • A graphic t-shirt, ripped jeans, and sneakers
  • A printed button-down shirt, black straight-cut pants, and loafers

4. Vibrant Birthstone Heart-Shaped Earrings

Give her your heart with these vibrant birthstone heart-shaped earrings! Choosing her birthstone adds extra special meaning to this Sweetest Day gift. The 10K gold studs are hypoallergenic and safe for the most sensitive skin. These heart-shaped earrings definitely say “I love you!” 


Not sure what her birthstone is or want to know more about the precious gemstone you’re about to choose for your special Sweetest Day gift for her? Read our complete guide to birthstones before making your selection.


A cute Sweetest Day gift for your girlfriend who loves:

  • Fun, feminine jewelry
  • The deep meaning of birthstones
  • Showing the world how much you love each other!

5. Modern Pear Shaped Black Onyx & Yellow Gold Earrings

If your woman prefers contemporary to cute, these are the earrings and Sweetest Day gift for her. 14K gold wraps two pear shaped black onyx gems in a modern look to match any outfit. Black onyx is a beautiful dark gemstone that perfectly complements the 14K yellow gold’s flawless and lustrous finish. The bezel stud adds subtle but noticeable detail. You can’t go wrong with earrings made with gemstones that represent love, peace, and harmony!


A modern Sweetest Day gift for your girlfriend who loves:

  • Contemporary jewelry
  • Adding subtle detail to everything
  • Simplicity and modern design

7. Tender Bangle Bracelet with Heart Lock Charm

Remind her that she holds the key to your heart with this tender bangle bracelet with a heart lock charm! Choose from silver, black, and rose to match her unique style. This lightweight bracelet is made out of durable stainless steel, meaning it will hug her wrist no matter where she goes. This bangle bracelet’s contemporary design makes it easy to wear with anything. Hint: Consider this layered look we featured on our Instagram for a truly unique gift!


A tender Sweetest Day gift for your girlfriend who loves:

  • Easy-to-wear, comfortable jewelry
  • Having go-to favorites for anything
  • Knowing you’re her forever and always!

8. Playful White Gold Dolphin Toe Ring 

This playful white gold dolphin toe ring is the perfect gift for a fun-loving girl! The 10K white gold adjustable toe ring features sparkly cubic zirconia to add some flash and warm her heart. The fun dolphin design reminds her of her beachy memories with you by her side. Pair this toe ring with a gift certificate for a pedicure for the ultimate pampered Sweetest Day gift!


A fun Sweetest Day gift for your girlfriend who loves:

  • Summer and long days at the beach
  • Playful jewelry
  • Thinking about your next destination vacation

9.  Lux Three-Stone Pavé Ring

This gorgeous three-stone pavé ring is lux for less! Three gemstones of your choice sparkle on top of the white sterling silver band. The ring exudes sophistication with its classy design. It’s a go-to piece of jewelry for the woman who loves putting together her own unique look every day.


A sophisticated Sweetest Day gift for your girlfriend who loves:

  • Beautiful jewelry she can wear every day
  • Looking good for less
  • Receiving meaningful gifts from the person she loves!

10.  Striking Diamond Star Pendant

Diamonds outline the double star design for a dazzling centerpiece to an outfit for a classy night out. Rose gold adds glowing warmth, while white gold is a timeless choice for this beautiful necklace. She’ll have stars in her eyes when she sees this on Sweetest Day!

A dazzling Sweetest Day gift for your girlfriend who loves:

  • Beautiful, quality jewelry for special occasions
  • Meaningful gifts
  • Looking her best on special nights out

Show us what you choose! Tell her to add #lovemylavari and #NationalSweetestDay to her Instagram, Facebook, and Twitter posts showing off your special gift to her. Looking for Sweetest Day gift ideas for him? Check out our blog post about trendy men’s jewelry.

Products Featured in this Post:

Item added to cart.
0 items - $0.00